Filial responsibility essay
To continue the relationship also when the parent is demented, is in fact the mirror image of the unconditional love the parent feels for a child. Therefore, Friendship Theory is a poor model for filial obligations.
Childrens rights with elderly parents
Findings regarding gender differences in attitudes toward responsibility have been mixed Ganong et al. Second, gratitude is in response to the motivations of another person, not only to the benefits or perceived benefits that person might provide. This rebuttal is a general one, applicable to any relationship in which one person is benefited very much by another person, but it is a feature which is present in many parent—child relationships. Brody, Elaine. In a normal relationship, it would be unusual to completely leave the father to fend for himself. With regard to eldercare, the general trend in Europe is to shift from institutional care to formal or informal homecare, and from in-kind to cash transfers Simonazzi , p. For children, it means that they are loved not because of who they are, but because of the relationship with the person who loves them.
Thus, rather than a friendship, the parent-child relationship is, or at least begins as, a relationship between unequal partners since parents shape who the child will become.
According to Welch, what is missing from the theory is a clear account of what changes in a relationship effect what filial obligations a child has and why.
Filial responsibility essay
Rickles-Jordan, A. Totowa: Humana Press; Fulfilling obligations in a particular instance does not preclude the continuous satisfaction of the conditions. Our societal conception of filial obligations is intimately connected with how we perceive our moral worth, and thus has important connections to discussions about family, social standing, and disability. The ability to so position oneself, however, depends on facts about the good in question that are likely to be unknown at the time one makes decisions about what career to pursue, where to live, what sort of family structure to create, and so forth. However, these patterns are mediated by the level of dependency of the elder and the size and gender composition of the family network Coward and Dwyer ; Matthews Daniels, Norman. Debt Theory a. At best, there is a contingent relation between people being related as parents and children and the chance that they have developed a friendship. The chapter presents the Friendship Theory of filial obligation. In fact, the general trend in long-term care policy, which has emphasized the benefits of community-based care, has been accompanied by a greater expectation of family care Finch ; Hendricks and Hatch Numerous explanations have been advanced to account for the observed divergence of caregiving behaviors between sons and daughters. Third, the care required to reach, and possibly enjoy, that longer life expectancy is often expensive. Kendall-Tackett, K. Most often, the delegation of responsibility for direct care to family is implicit rather than explicit.
Analogously, a child owes more to a parent who sacrificed a great deal than she would owe to a parent whose sacrifice was less substantial. The first interpretation is that parent-child relationships are, when things go well, reciprocal insofar as both the parent and child benefit from the relationship.
Ali Jackson, N. What if someone does not care? Stuifbergen, M.
Despite its intuitive appeal, the idea that we might have special obligations to someone in virtue of our relationship with them is a philosophically problematic one. If the child has asked for this payment, then the investment is a favor and the child owes repayment. The question what adult children owe their parents is not only philosophically interesting, but also of increasing relevance in ageing societies.
based on 85 review